Over the past decade or two, transgenderism has become a key part of the political and social agenda of the American left. As a result, countless adults and young people have been deceived into embracing untrue identities that are at odds with every cell in their bodies. Some of those individuals have done great damage to themselves by pursuing surgeries and other “treatments” in a failed attempt to align their bodies with those untrue identities. Furthermore, girls and young women have experienced the unfairness of competing in sports against males who claim to be “transgender,” to say nothing of the indignity of sharing locker room space with those same males. In New York, our public education system has been reshaped to accommodate and perpetuate transgenderism. Until recently, even the U.S. Armed Forces had been directed to bow the knee to “transgender” orthodoxy.
In recent years, progress has been made in countering transgenderism. President Donald Trump has issued multiple executive orders aimed at curbing the influence of transgenderism, both inside and outside the federal government. Twenty-four states have passed Help Not Harm laws that protect minor children from gender transition procedures, and twenty-five states have passed Save Girls’ Sports laws. And various corporations have backed away from militantly pro-“transgender” policies and business practices.
On May 6, 2025, members of a New York State Senate committee—Republicans and Democrats alike—took a step to counter the transgender agenda.
Earlier this year, two brave state legislators—Sen. Steve Rhoads (R-Bellmore) and Asm. John Mikulin (R-Bethpage)—introduced a bill to uphold schools’ freedom to protect the integrity of girls’ sports. Bill S.460-Rhoads/A.8239-Mikulin would allow every school to opt out of any rule or regulation that permits boys to play on girls’ sports teams if such school finds that male participation “would have an adverse effect on the physical or emotional safety of female participants, or would adversely impact a female student’s ability to participate successfully in such interschool athletic competition…” This bill is exactly the type of bill that most—if not all—Democratic committee chairs in New York would completely ignore. On March 19, however, Sen. Rhoads filed a motion requesting that the Senate Education Committee consider his bill. The filing of that motion required the committee to place the bill on its agenda within 45 days.
At the Senate Education Committee meeting on May 6, Sen. Rhoads’s bill was brought up for consideration. A spirited discussion ensued.
After Sen. Alexis Weik (R-Sayville) expressed support for the legislation, Sen. John Liu (D-Queens) thanked the committee chair, Sen. Shelley Mayer (D-Yonkers) for “entertaining this ridiculous bill.” Sen. Weik objected to Sen. Liu’s insulting remark; undeterred, Sen. Liu began attacking the bill, claiming that it would “harm transgender as well as cisgender”[1] girls. Sen. Liu added that the bill “perpetuates—very dangerously—some of the very stereotypes that we have worked long and hard [against] in this state to bring about equality.” The Senator did not identify even one stereotype that the bill would perpetuate; he did, however, go on to confuse the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) with the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP).
Sen. Bill Weber (R-Nanuet) took exception to Sen. Liu’s remarks. “I don’t think you have high school girls in sports. I do,” said Sen. Weber. Sen. Weber stated that his son ran the 400-meter dash in 51 seconds, while the fastest high school girl in New York ran the same race in 55 seconds. Sen. Weber noted that “science doesn’t lie,” adding that he sees the impact of sex differences on sports achievement “every day.”
Sen. Jim. Tedisco chimed in, asserting that male athletes should not be allowed to displace female athletes “who work hard, who want to be everything they can be.” Sen. Tedisco added, “You cannot change XY and XX.”
Calling the bill “mean-spirited and misguided,” Sen. Mayer asserted that it was “unfortunate that this bill is before us.”
Sen. Liu spoke up again, inaccurately claiming that “if somebody feels that they are not their biological gender, well, that’s how they feel. That is who they are.”
Sen. Weik, a certified personal trainer, then made the following remarks: “Genetically speaking, whether you believe in the science or not, men and women are different. And we compete differently. That’s why the Olympics has men’s sports and women’s sports. Genetic women cannot normally achieve the same numbers than genetic men can… It’s an unfair disadvantage.” The Senator added, “The [Democratic] majority tends to brag and boast they they’ve got mostly female members. And yet you’re undercutting females… I feel this is just a terrible thing for New York State, the fact that we’re lumping men and women together and calling them the same thing and thinking that they’re going to achieve” at the same level in sports.
Following the debate, a vote was held on Bill S.460-Rhoads/A.8239-Mikulin. Often, when State Senate committees consider bills relating to matters of sexual orientation or gender identity, the result is a party-line vote in which Democrats support the LGBT side and Republicans do not. This vote was different.
All five Republican members (Sens. Stephen Chan and Dan Stec, along with Sens. Tedisco, Weber, and Weik) voted for the bill, six Democratic members (Sens. Cordell Cleare, Robert Jackson, Julia Salazar, and Toby Ann Stavisky, along with Sens. Liu and Mayer) voted against it, and three other Democratic members (Sens. Joe Addabbo, Siela Bynoe, and Monica Martinez[2]) voted “aye without recommendation.” (An “aye without recommendation” vote is a vote to advance a bill to the next stage of the legislative process without taking a position on whether the bill should become law.) The overall result? An 8-6 vote to advance the bill to the Senate Codes Committee.
In other words, a bill that is opposed by “transgender” advocates was approved by a New York State Senate committee—and three Democrats helped to approve it.
Does this mean that Bill S.460-Rhoads/A.8239-Mikulin has a chance of becoming law? In the near term, the answer is no. What is does mean, though, is that at least some Democrats are second-guessing the political wisdom of their party’s continued embrace of gender insanity. And that is good news.
New York Families thanks each member of the Senate Education Committee who voted for Bill S.460-Rhoads/A.8239-Mikulin, as well as each member who spoke in favor of it.
[1] The word “cisgender” is a made-up word that “transgender” activists and their allies use to refer to persons who are not “transgender.”
[2] Sen. Martinez stated that she did not wish to oppose the bill without discussing it with its sponsor, Sen. Rhoads, who was not in the room. Sen. Martinez added, “‘We have done so much in the state of New York to assist our LGBTQ community and for us not to have an actual valid discussion with the sponsor I think is unfair.’”